Force Majeure and Reasonable Endeavors Explained

Force Majeure and Reasonable Endeavors Explained

In May 2024, the U.K. Supreme Court delivered a key judgment in RTI Ltd. v. MUR Shipping BV, shedding light on two significant questions in contractual law: (1) what does a “reasonable endeavors” obligation demand within a force majeure clause, and (2) whether a party relying on force majeure must accept non-contractual workarounds.

Force Majeure is a legal concept designed to relieve parties from contractual obligations when unforeseen events outside their control make performance impossible. Traditionally, these clauses are shaped by the contract’s wording rather than general legal doctrines, offering contractual freedom and certainty. They often include “reasonable endeavors” carve-outs, meaning a party isn’t excused from non-performance unless it tries to overcome the force majeure event.

Recent years have seen a surge in force majeure-related disputes, especially following the global impact of Covid-19, the U.K.’s exit from the EU, the Russia-Ukraine and the Israel-Hamas-Hizballah-Iran wars. For instance, in PD Teesport Ltd. v. P&O North Sea Ferries Ltd., the court examined whether Brexit and Covid-19 could excuse non-performance. Although both were accepted as force majeure events, the court highlighted the importance of linking specific contract terms to the event’s impact. A broad reliance on force majeure wasn’t enough; precise, event-specific evidence was required.

Force majeure clauses have also intersected with sanctions in more recent cases. In Lamesa Investments Ltd. v. Cynergy Bank Ltd., the Court of Appeal considered whether a party could avoid repaying a loan to a sanctioned entity, despite U.S. law not explicitly forbidding payment. The court ruled that avoiding secondary sanctions was valid grounds for non-payment, broadening how force majeure clauses could be interpreted when foreign sanctions are involved.

The recent MUR Shipping case brings this evolving interpretation to the forefront. In this case, MUR Shipping and RTI Limited had a contract for shipping bauxite, but when RTI’s parent company, Rusal was sanctioned by the U.S., MUR invoked force majeure, claiming they couldn’t accept U.S. dollar payments due to sanctions. RTI proposed paying in euros as a workaround, but MUR refused. RTI argued that MUR should have accepted this alternative under the “reasonable endeavors” clause.

The initial ruling favored RTI, suggesting that accepting payment in euros could have overcome the force majeure. However, the U.K. Supreme Court eventually sided with MUR, ruling that the force majeure clause did not require MUR to accept non-contractual alternatives. The court clarified that the contract’s explicit terms, not external notions of reasonableness, determine what constitutes performance. Accepting non-contractual alternatives could lead to unpredictable outcomes, undermining the core principle of contractual certainty.

The judgment emphasizes the importance of clarity in contract drafting. For companies operating in today’s unstable global environment, it’s vital to decide whether contracts should allow for non-contractual performance under force majeure clauses. Otherwise, absent explicit language, parties relying on force majeure are under no obligation to accept workarounds, even if they seem reasonable in practice.

This case marks a critical moment in contractual interpretation, highlighting the court’s preference for upholding the sanctity of contracts and ensuring that parties are bound by the precise wording of their agreements.


DISCLAIMER

This content is brought to you for informational purposes only, you should not construe any such information or other material as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice. Nothing contained on this website constitutes a solicitation, recommendation, endorsement, or offer by any person or any third party service provider to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in this or in in any other jurisdiction in which such solicitation or offer would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction.

THIS ARTICLE IS PROVIDED FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND DO NOT CONSTITUTE LEGAL ADVICE. THIS ARTICLE IS PROVIDED WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING AS TO ITS LEGAL EFFECT AND COMPLETENESS. THE INFORMATION SHOULD BE USED AS A GUIDE AND MODIFIED TO MEET YOUR OWN INDIVIDUAL NEEDS AND THE LAWS OF YOUR STATE, BY INDEPENDENT COUNSEL YOU RETAIN. YOUR USE OF ANY INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS ARTICLE, IS AT YOUR OWN RISK. WE, OUR EMPLOYEES, CONTRACTORS, OR ATTORNEYS WHO PARTICIPATED IN PROVIDING THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, EXPRESSLY DISCLAIM ANY WARRANTY, AND BY DOWNLOADING OR USING OR RELYING ON THIS ARTICLE; NO ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIPS ARE CREATED. DO NOT USE THIS ARTICLE WITHOUT AN INDEPENDENT LAWYER YOU HAVE SPECIFICALLY RETAINED FOR SUCH PURPOSE.

© 2024 Yair Udi – Law Offices. All rights reserved

Need Help?